WilmerHale Partner Ari Holtzblatt was named Litigator of the (Past) Week by Litigation Daily for securing a significant First Amendment victory for LinkedIn in the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit concerning government demands for reporters’ records.
The recognition follows a published Fourth Circuit decision holding that a government demand for 18 months of LinkedIn metadata from journalists was “substantially overbroad” because it threatened to expose the identities of journalists’ confidential sources who were unrelated to a government leak investigation. That “could not help but deal a damaging blow to First Amendment freedoms,” the Fourth Circuit said in an opinion written by Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson III.
The court also concluded that a lack of relevance and materiality can itself constitute an “undue burden” under the Stored Communications Act and that LinkedIn must be allowed to inform a previously vetted attorney for the reporters’ news organization unless the government presented persuasive evidence that such a limited disclosure would compromise its investigation. The court sent the disclosure and secrecy orders back to the district court to be narrowed.
In a Q&A with Litigation Daily, Holtzblatt discussed the First Amendment issues at stake, Microsoft’s and LinkedIn’s approach to balancing national security interests with protections for newsgathering and confidential sources, and the potential significance of the decision for technology companies responding to government demands for customer information.
Holtzblatt argued the appeal and led the litigation with partners Aaron Zebley and Siddharth Velamoor. The WilmerHale team also included Hilary Hurd, Matt Morris, Leah Fugere and Andrew Nell.
Read the full Q&A in Litigation Daily.