Practice Tips for Presenting and Responding to Motivation-to-Combine Arguments in IPR Proceedings

Practice Tips for Presenting and Responding to Motivation-to-Combine Arguments in IPR Proceedings

Publication

Related Documents

Related Solutions

Providing comprehensive solutions for the acquisition, enforcement and protection of IP.
A global team handling highly complex and sensitive matters in all aspects of litigation.
Clients trust us to protect their most important intellectual property matters.
We advise clients on the smartest, most cost-effective ways to challenge or defend issued patents.

David Cavanaugh, Joshua Stern and Kevin Yurkerwich, in this article published by Bloomberg BNA's Patent, Trademark & Copyright Journal, provide an overview of recent Patent Trial and Appeal Board decisions denying institution of inter partes review (IPR) based on the failure of a petitioner to sufficiently articulate a motivation or reason to combine, and share practice tips for practitioners to follow when either drafting a petition that relies on obviousness or preparing a preliminary response.

In IPR proceedings, the preliminary response allows a patent owner to argue that an IPR proceeding should not be instituted. One way a patent owner may oppose institution of an obviousness ground that relies on multiple references or teachings is to argue that the petition does not adequately articulate a motivation or reasons why a person of ordinary skill in the art would combine the cited prior art references or teachings. Indeed, the Federal Circuit recently confirmed the role that motivation to combine arguments can play in IPR proceedings, holding that the Patent Trial and Appeal Board "must make a finding of a motivation to combine when it is disputed." Read the full article

Authors

Notice

We appreciate your interest in WilmerHale. While we are pleased to have you contact us, please keep in mind that merely contacting WilmerHale does not create an attorney-client relationship. Such a relationship will not arise until the Firm agrees in writing to represent you in connection with a particular matter. Importantly, unless and until this has occurred, you should not provide us with any confidential information, and we have no duty to keep confidential any information that we may receive from you. Thank you for your understanding.

I Accept Cancel