In That Case: West Virginia v. B.P.J.

In That Case: West Virginia v. B.P.J.

Podcast In the Public Interest

Episode Guests

In the Public Interest is excited to continue its 2026 Supreme Court miniseries examining notable decisions issued by the US Supreme Court. In this episode, guest host Daniel Volchok, vice chair of WilmerHale’s Appellate and Supreme Court Litigation Practice Group, speaks with Partner-in-Charge of WilmerHale's Denver office and Co-Chair of the Intellectual Property Litigation Group Mindy Sooter and Senior Associate Dana Bradley about West Virginia v. B.P.J. This closely watched case concerned Title IX, the Equal Protection Clause and state restrictions on the participation of transgender girls and women on sports teams consistent with their gender identity.   

Volchok, Sooter and Bradley discuss the statutory and constitutional arguments before the Court, as well as the Court’s decision that laws prohibiting transgender women from competing on women’s teams are permissible under Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause. They also explore the decision’s intentionally narrow scope, the questions it leaves unresolved and what the ruling may mean for schools, athletic institutions and future litigation involving transgender participation in athletics. 

Related Resources 

Hosts

Episode Transcript

Expand All Collapse All
  • Transcript

    +

    Felicia Ellsworth: Welcome to In the Public Interest, a podcast from WilmerHale. My name is Felicia Ellsworth.

    Jekkie Kim: And I’m Jekkie Kim. Felicia and I are partners at WilmerHale, an international law firm that works at the intersection of government, innovation, and business. This episode is a continuation of our 2026 Supreme Court miniseries. Today, we’ll be discussing West Virginia v. B.P.J., a closely watched dispute concerning Title IX, equal protection, and eligibility rules for participation in school sports. We will hear from WilmerHale Partner Daniel Volchok, who sat down with Partner Mindy Sooter and Senior Associate Dana Bradley in WilmerHale’s Denver office to discuss the Court’s reasoning, the competing constitutional and statutory arguments, and what the decision may mean for schools, students, and future Title IX litigation. To explore the case in greater detail, I’ll turn things over to Daniel, Mindy, and Dana.

    Daniel Volchok: I’m Daniel Volchok, the vice chair of WilmerHale’s Appellate and Supreme Court Litigation Practice Group. And on this episode, we’ll be discussing the Court’s decision in West Virginia v. B.P.J., which concerns states’ restrictions on the ability of transgender girls and women to play on sports teams consistent with their gender identity. The decision comes down at a time when there is a lot of attention on transgender policies. For example, on President Trump’s first day back in office, he issued an executive order on the subject titled, “Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government.” The West Virginia case in the Supreme Court didn’t involve that order, but its decision sheds a little light on how policy priorities in this area hold up to legal scrutiny. Joining me to discuss the case are Mindy Sooter, a partner in WilmerHale’s Denver office, and Dana Bradley, a senior associate in that same office. Mindy and Dana have worked together on pro bono representations regarding transgender rights. Mindy and Dana, thank you so much for joining us on this episode of our Supreme Court miniseries.

    Mindy Sooter: Thank you, Daniel, for that nice introduction, and it’s great to be here today.

    Dana Bradley: Thank you so much, Daniel. Happy to be here.

    Daniel Volchok: Okay, so let’s start with the basics of the litigation. Who were the parties in the case, and how did it get started?

    Dana Bradley: This case arises out of a consolidated action of two cases, one coming out of Idaho, Little v. Hecox, and one coming out of West Virginia, West Virginia v. B.P.J. In B.P.J., the plaintiff is a transgender girl who challenged a West Virginia law that restricts transgender girls and women from participating on athletic teams consistent with their gender identity under Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution. In Hecox, the plaintiff was a transgender woman who was trying out for the track and field team at her college, and she challenged an Idaho law that restricted participation of trans girls and women on sports teams consistent with their gender identity under the Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution. And importantly, in both cases, the plaintiffs were trans girls who had either been on puberty blockers previously and therefore had not undergone your typical biological male puberty or were receiving hormone therapy.

    Daniel Volchok: You mentioned Title IX, one of the sources of law that was at issue in the case. That’s a federal statute, as our listeners may know, enacted back in 1972. Can you give us some more background on that statute?

    Mindy Sooter: Many folks have probably heard of Title IX and have a general sense that it’s promoted women’s athletics over the last several decades. But just to dive into a few more specifics, Title IX refers to an education statute passed in 1972, so over 50 years ago. And broadly, it prohibits discrimination under any education program or activity on the basis of sex if that program receives federal financial assistance. It might come as a surprise that Title IX doesn’t explicitly address sports, but shortly after it was passed, Congress recognized that and also passed what’s known as the Javits Amendment. And that amendment clarified that Title IX applies to athletic activities, and it required the government to promulgate regulations prohibiting discrimination in sports. And most relevant for the Supreme Court’s opinion here, any provisions or regulations preventing discrimination in sports must be reasonable, considering the nature of the particular sports. Title IX is regarded as a wide success. In contrast to 1972, when there were only about 300,000 girls playing in high school sports, there are now about 3.5 million girls playing high school sports. And in college, the number of sports teams for women, their opportunities, and scholarships has also grown exponentially. And it’s under this statute that one of the cases, the West Virginia case, was decided.

    Daniel Volchok: All right, let’s get into the case itself. What were the plaintiffs challenging? And then what were the party’s arguments under Title IX, as well as the Equal Protection Clause mentioned earlier?

    Dana Bradley: Both plaintiffs were challenging categorical bans on transgender girls competing in sports. Essentially, under Title IX, as Mindy was mentioning, the Javits Amendments required that the restrictions be reasonable. And so really central to the arguments of both plaintiffs is the fact that they had undergone some sort of hormone therapy or had been on puberty blockers and therefore had not experienced the same puberty that a biological male would. So as far as the Title IX argument goes, the argument was that the restriction on trans girls and women in sports was not a reasonable provision under Title IX because if they had received that treatment, if they had been on hormones before, then they did not have the same sort of physical advantages, because transgender girls who have been on hormone therapy do not have the same inherent physical advantages that biological males have. As far as equal protection goes, the argument was that categorical restrictions against transgender girls competing in sports does not substantially advance the state’s interest of competitive fairness and safety when applied to transgender women and girls who have been on either puberty blockers or hormone therapy. The argument of the state, on the other hand, was that the restrictions are substantially related to the interest in maintaining the safety and competitive fairness of girls’ and women’s sports.

    Daniel Volchok: All right, so those are the arguments that the parties are putting in front of the courts. Before we get to the Supreme Court, what happened in the lower courts?

    Mindy Sooter: Both of these cases involve challenges to existing statutes, one in West Virginia and one in Idaho. In the West Virginia case, B.P.J. sued the state in federal court, and that court initially issued a preliminary injunction against the state that allowed B.P.J. to compete while the case went on. Later, the West Virginia District Court granted summary judgment before a trial, agreeing with the state and dissolving the injunction, finding against B.P.J. Now on appeal, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed on Title IX, finding in favor of B.P.J, but it decided it could not resolve the equal protection claim because there were still disputed facts that needed to be resolved by the district court. In the Idaho case, Ms. Hecox won a preliminary injunction barring enforcement of the Idaho statute preventing trans females from participating on the women’s sports teams, and the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals agreed. When the Supreme Court decided to take up these consolidated cases, though, Ms. Hecox decided, and stipulated in fact, that she would no longer compete on the women’s team and that her case was therefore moot, seeking to take the case outside of the hands of the Supreme Court. But as you’ll find out, the Supreme Court rejected that argument and took it up anyway.

    Daniel Volchok: Okay, so the Court does take up both cases. It consolidates them. The parties put in their briefs, their written submissions, and then we get to the oral argument that you just mentioned. And what were some of the notable takeaways from the argument?

    Dana Bradley: There was a considerable amount of discussion regarding the Bostock case. Now for background, the Bostock case refers to a 2020 case handed down from the Court, Bostock v. Clayton County, Georgia. The question there, under Title VII, which is an anti-discrimination statute in the context of employment law, was essentially if discrimination on the basis of gender identity and sexual orientation constitutes sex discrimination under Title VII. This question came up a lot during oral argument because the central thesis of the Bostock case is that discrimination on the basis of transgender status is necessarily discrimination on the basis of sex because you cannot separate the two. Being transgender is essentially someone whose gender identity does not align with their sex assigned at birth and therefore sex is at the center of the inquiry no matter what. Given the textual similarities here, the justices had questions, naturally, about what makes Title IX different when both Title VII and Title IX refer to sex and sex discrimination. And the answer from West Virginia was that Bostock is essentially about status-based discrimination, and West Virginia did not ban transgender athletes. Instead, they drew a line based on biological sex. Another big point that was raised here was the difference in context between Title VII and Title IX, and the sports context of Title IX played a fundamental role in the different result here. Justice Jackson’s line of questioning concerned disparate impact. She pushed both West Virginia and the US Solicitor General on what she called “second order discrimination.” The first order separating boys from girls and the second order separating transgender girls from cisgender girls. The Solicitor General concedes that there is a very significant disparate impact on transgender individuals, but states, just as West Virginia’s counsel did, that Title IX doesn’t cover disparate impact. This portion of the arguments, though, does not actually show up in the majority opinion.

    Daniel Volchok: All right, so let’s get to the majority opinion. The Court hears oral argument, takes the case under submission, spends a few months mulling over it, and we get the decision at the very end of the term on June 30. What did the Court hold? What was its reasoning? And give us the breakdown among the nine justices.

    Mindy Sooter: The bottom line is that the Court found in favor of the states, deciding that laws prohibiting transgender women from competing on women’s teams are permissible under both Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause. As for the lineup, Justice Kavanaugh wrote for the Court; he was joined by Chief Justice Roberts and Justices Alito, Barrett, Gorsuch, and Thomas. We also saw Justice Sotomayor, who filed an opinion concurring in part and dissenting in part, and she was joined by Justices Kagan and Jackson. Like many recent opinions, it was rather splintered. Starting with Title IX and focusing on the majority reasoning, the Court framed the question as whether it was reasonable for schools to “maintain women’s and girls’ sports for biological females.” And the Court answered that question in the affirmative. The Court emphasized that there was no dispute whatsoever among the parties that sex in Title IX means biological sex. So they focus their analysis on reasonableness and they found ultimately that it was reasonable to make categorical distinctions based on biological sex. The Court relied heavily on a factual finding allowing biological males to play on women’s and girls’ teams can put women and girls at risk of injuries or unfair competition. And the majority further found that Title IX does not guarantee every student a spot on the team’s roster. So that’s Title IX in a nutshell.

    Dana Bradley: And the equal protection analysis really hinges on the fit between the problem that the government is trying to solve and the means that the government is using to solve that problem. And there are different levels of review. For example, with laws that discriminate against so-called suspect classifications, such as race or ethnicity, the Court applies strict scrutiny. Under strict scrutiny, the states would have to prove that a law is narrowly tailored and use the least restrictive means to achieve a compelling government interest. When laws discriminate along other important classifications, like sex or gender, the Court applies a test called intermediate scrutiny, which requires the states to prove that a law is substantially related to an important government interest. The third level is rational basis review, which is the lowest bar, and essentially the state only has to prove that there is a rational basis for them taking the action that they did. In this case, the Court actually said that it did not need to decide whether intermediate or strict scrutiny applies because the stated rationale satisfied either test. The Court accepted that the state imposed a categorical ban in the interest of safety and competitive fairness.

    Daniel Volchok: All right, so the Court upholds the categorical restrictions barring trans girls and women from participating in sports teams consistent with their gender identity. What then remains unresolved in this area after the decision?

    Dana Bradley: So the Court intentionally makes this a very narrow decision. The first significant takeaway is that all this decision says is that these restrictions, these categorical bars are permitted. The Court’s decision does not require states to implement these types of restrictions. However, as we mentioned, there is a lot that the Court does not say. For example, the decision does not state whether states, athletic associations, or institutions may adopt transgender-inclusive athletic policies, nor does the decision resolve numerous related questions involving transgender boys and men, participation in team practices rather than competition, how these questions play in non-athletic contexts and intimate spaces, and institutional obligations that arise as a result of this decision.

    Daniel Volchok: And talking more specifically about the coming months and years, the Trump Administration called the ruling a resounding victory for its agenda. But what can educational institutions expect in the coming years because of B.P.J.?

    Mindy Sooter: Well Daniel, there are some things that we’ve already started to see. And just to take a step back, if you keep in mind that while the Court observed that the majority of states and some other athletic institutions have regulations or rules prohibiting participation of trans women in women’s sports, not all do. So there are many teams in the US that do still allow trans women to participate. But we’ve started seeing, and we may see more investigations and lawsuits from biological women who are on those teams complaining that they’re entitled to biological women-only facilities—things like housing, locker rooms, restroom facilities—requiring under one of these statutes or the Constitution that they have gender-restricted facilities. In fact, we’re seeing the Department of Education and the Department of Justice who are already conducting exactly these types of investigations now, perhaps in an effort to discourage these teams from including trans women. We don’t know, but we can only surmise. Of course, that type of administration enforcement is dependent on the political views of the administration, and that may change over time. And there may be other examples that come to light. In fact, as the facts evolve, we may find that we’re revisiting this decision in the future under another Court.

    Daniel Volchok: So the issues will continue to have prominence inside and outside the courtroom, in our public discourse, and certainly in individuals’ lives. Mindy and Dana, thank you so much for speaking with us today about this topic and this very important case.

    Mindy Sooter: Thank you, Daniel.

    Dana Bradley: Thank you for having us.

    Felicia Ellsworth: And thank you to our listeners. If you enjoy this podcast, please take a minute to share with a friend and subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen to your podcast. If you have any questions regarding this episode, please email them to us at [email protected].

    Jekkie Kim: For our WilmerHale alumni in the audience, if you haven’t already, please join our alumni center at alumni.wilmerhale.com so we can stay better connected. Special thank you to the producers of this episode, Artha Jonassaint and Maria Kanevsky. Sound engineering and editing by Bryan Benenati, marketing by Allison Khan and Alexandra Thimble, all under the leadership of executive producers Jake Brownell, Kaylene Khosla, and Arpi Youssoufian. Thank you for listening.

    Felicia Ellsworth: See you next time on In the Public Interest.

More from this series

Notice

We appreciate your interest in WilmerHale. While we are pleased to have you contact us, please keep in mind that merely contacting WilmerHale does not create an attorney-client relationship. Such a relationship will not arise until the Firm agrees in writing to represent you in connection with a particular matter. Importantly, unless and until this has occurred, you should not provide us with any confidential information, and we have no duty to keep confidential any information that we may receive from you. Thank you for your understanding.